Self Employed or Not?

Are freelance grooms truly self employed, or are they infact employees?

Leading Barrister Victoria von Wachter from 5 Essex Court looks at a recent ruling.

"Employers take note – the recent judgment in Uber v Aslan made it to the Supreme Court and the company’s appeal was unsuccessful – the drivers were held to be workers and therefore entitled to holiday and sick pay.

Whilst the case centred on whether the drivers were self-employed or ‘workers’ the same approach has been commonplace when the Employment Tribunal considers whether or not a person is self-employed or an employee.

Employers remember – if that ‘freelance’ or ‘self-employed’ groom is held to be any employee then you are responsible not only for back employer’s statutory contributions but those that relate to the groom.

The question therefore has to be – do you feel lucky?"

What about if the groom chooses to be self-employed - What should an employer do?

The simple answer is to refuse but there might be some wriggle room if the applicant is determined and can show evidence of a trading history as a sole operator or limited company. Then I suggest writing and confirming that employee status has been offered and is preferred, but that the groom has insisted on self-employed status. Get the groom to sign to indicate agreement.

What about a groom who has multiple clients and decides who they work for and when they work?

This looks far more like a conventional self-employed situation but it is even better if the groom brings their own tools and can be shown to have refused work every now and then, likewise it is a good piece of evidence if it can be shown the groom offers to work but is declined by the employer.

What about a groom who works for me regularly eg. every morning, but also works for someone else in the afternoon?

Both situations indicate employed status – employees can work for more than one employer. 



Need more support? As an Equestrian Employers Association member you get free access to the 5 Essex Court initial phone consultation helpline.